"What's Your Best Price?"

Soon after reading this post I received an email (just yesterday) from a potential buyer with that god awful question "What is the absolute bottom dollar you would accept". Well I thought for a few moments as to how I should answer this, a smart a-- response or be nice. I took the nice route thinking I do want to sell these speakers and hey, you never know. Today I got the "thanks but I found something cheaper and closer. Most responses to this post agree that this question rarely ends in a sale and now I am a believer too, I'm going for the smart a-- response next time.

I have to add that on Head-Fi (and on other hobbyist sites) they do not have an eBay-like system that AudioGon has. So there is no way to "bid" on those items.

I take exception to suggestiong only the buyer gets to dictate pricing. I have not only asked a buyer what their best price is but have also been asked that question on an item I had for sale. In several instances, on both sides of the transaction, it has resulted in a completed transaction. I have an excellent reputation and have many references. I have 40+ transaction on Head-Fi and 100's of other on other hobbyist sited through the years. Many of which are high dolllar items. I'm hardly a newbie.

Ignoring anyone who asks for a best price only reduces the potential for sale. I prefer to expand all my potential options. It doesn't take that much time or effort to send an email or response. I've had people who never even discussed price, had me send many pics, ask many questions, commit to purchases only to flake out. There are many things in business transactions that are frustrating. That's just business. If I'm selling something, anyone is free to ask me any legit question they want. I promise I won't whine about it later. At least not publicly. LoL :)

I'm going for the smart a-- response next time.
Markpao (Threads | Answers | This Thread)

I don't believe replying with, "What's your best offer?" is a smart a** response. I think it's perfectly reasonable if the buyer started off with, "What's your best price?".

I used to list items at a fixed price, which was my lowest acceptable price. I still received offers, including the bone headed, "What's your best price?"

Hey, if I have a fixed price listing, it shouldn't take a brain surgeon to figure out my lowest acceptable price.

Nevertheless, some people don't get it.

Now, I just list the asking price, and assume offers will follow. I'm happy to negotiate with serious buyers.

Baka1969, you are right, up to a point. It IS just business.

Tvad, I think this may be that if MSRP was $1200 and it is listed at $800 and you get it for $500 that is a much better deal than it being listed at $500 and paying "full price" for it. $500 is not always $500.

Tvad, I think this may be that if MSRP was $1200 and it is listed at $800 and you get it for $500 that is a much better deal than it being listed at $500 and paying "full price" for it. $500 is not always $500.
T_bone (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

That's pretty funny.

In your example, both buyers paid $500. Bottom line. Buyer #1 may think he got a better deal, but it's not true.

This is a game to some.