To Float or not to Float...


I have a DeHavilland preamp which has a switch allowing one to "float" the ground.  I've always used it in the "float" position, however recently, perhaps due to some connectivity issues with my interconnects, there is a small buzz emanating from my speakers with the switch in this position.  The buzz disappears when I flip the preamp switch to the "ground" position.  Irrespective of the buzzing, is there any sonic advantage (or disadvantage) to "floating" the preamp ground in this situation??
Thanks for your informed opinions...

weebeesdad
weebeesdad OP
54 posts                                                                            09-12-2017 12:48pm

Thanks for all of your responses. Cleeds triggered the solution when he (or she) wrote "a properly grounded power cord", which reminded me that I was having intermittent problems with the connecting plug of the preamp’s power cord. Swapped out the power cord and problem solved. I also have a pair of DeHavilland mono block amps with the same ground/float switches, and in the manual it states that leaving the switch in the "float" position may result in a "cleaner sound". At any rate, a fully functioning grounded power cord has done the trick...
@weebeesdad,

I checked and was told the ground lift switch lifts the signal circuit from the chassis/AC mains safety equipment ground.
The AC mains safety equipment ground is always connected to the chassis of deHavilland audio equipment for electrical safety.
It is recommended the user "float" both deHavilland mono blocks and close the ground lift switch on the preamp.

The chassis of the power amps will still be grounded, connected, to the AC mains power outlet safety equipment ground.

Jim

Thanks, Jim.  I also use the preamp with a solid state amp that has no ground lifting switch, and keep the preamp switch in the "float" position.  Any danger in that?? 


@weebeesdad ,

No danger at all. The switch only lifts the audio circuit from the chassis ground.
(The AC mains safety equipment ground)

The AC mains safety equipment ground remains connected to the chassis at all times. In the event of a Hot to chassis ground fault event the safety equipment ground wire in the power cord connected to the preamp will carry the fault current to the wall receptacle equipment ground contact.

Are you using the preamp with the SS amp at the present time with the switch on the preamp in the float position?
I also use the preamp with a solid state amp that has no ground lifting switch, and keep the preamp switch in the "float" position.

Jim

Jim -
I have always used the preamp in the "float" position, whether it was with a solid state or tube (including the DeHavilland mono blocks) amp.  My impression was that sonically this was the preferred position, and as I mentioned the manual for the mono blocks even states a potential sonic improvement keeping the switches in the "float" position as long as there are no accompanying noises or buzzes (I can't seem to find the preamp manual to check, however it was planted in my head from somewhere (probably the manual) to keep that switch at "float").  Only recently did the buzzing begin which corresponded with some connectivity problems related to the preamp's power cord.  Now that I have switched to a different power cord, there is no more buzzing or noise, and all grounding switches are set at "float". 



weebeesdad said: 09-16-2017 7:54pm

Now that I have switched to a different power cord, there is no more buzzing or noise, and all grounding switches are set at "float".
I would say that rules out an interconnect/s causing the buzzing problem.
Audio system sounds fine now, no buzzing, same interconnects.

Through experimenting, listening, you found the power cord you were using on the preamp was causing the buzzing sound you were hearing.

Exactly why is still the unknown, imo.

What puzzled me you said, in an earlier post, when you closed the ground lift switch the buzzing would stop. If the integrity of the continuity of the equipment ground wire connection, of the power cord, was compromised somewhere from the male plug >>> through the IEC connector, >>> through the ground contact of the preamp IEC inlet connector, closing the ground lift switch would not make any difference. But you found closing the float ground switch did.....

What exactly could be the cause of the buzz? At one point I considered poor contact pressure between the hot and or neutral current carrying conductors between the IEC female connector, on the end of the power cord, and the male inlet connector on the back of the preamp. Even a slight arcing would induce RF noise into the preamp, imo. Sounds plausible to me.....

But why closing the ground lift switch would stop the buzzing sound?
When closed it connects the preamp’s audio circuitry, signal ground circuit, back to the chassis of the preamp.

This is where John Curl would say, this is where the test equipment is brought on board to measure and found out the why.

Something to throw into mix of thought for the why. Here is a response from Charles Hansen to a post of mine.
Close

< < The AC power wiring is double insulated. The case is floating.... > >

Actually the case is connected to the signal ground of the internal circuitry.

I think the main reason that most manufacturers use 3 wire power cords with a safety ground is ignorance. It’s the easiest way to ensure safety, and it’s also the method most commonly espoused in textbooks.

Kind of like FETs versus bipolar transistors. All the textbooks focus on bipolars. Not much is generally known about FETs. So designers follow the path of least resistance. It’s too much work to dig up all the stuff to learn about some other technology like FETs or double insulation.

And then his response to another post of mine.
RE: Thanks Charles for your response, but you left us, me, hanging.

The only way that the case can provide any shielding for the audio circuitry is if it is connected to the signal ground. In addition, if it is left unconnected from the signal ground, then it will create unwanted capacitive feedback loops (both positive and negative) between various parts of the circuitry. Refer to Morrison’s books for additional details.
https://db.audioasylum.com/mhtml/m.html?forum=general&n=525553&highlight=double+insulated+po...

Now keep in mind the responses from Mr. Hansen are in response to my posts for audio equipment that have double insulated AC power wiring where the power cord is 2 wire with a 2 prong plug. AC mains equipment ground is not used.

So how does the above relate to your situation? Not really sure.
But what if the AC mains equipment ground is broken, open, somewhere in the bad power cord. No continuity, or sometimes intermittent continuity. With the ground lift set to float wouldn’t the chassis be acting exactly as Mr. Hansen said in his post?

All just conjuncture on my part.....

Al, (almarg),

If you are reading this post of mine what are your thoughts on the "why the buzz"

~ ~ ~ ~ ~
@weebeesdad,

Question.
What are you using for front end sources connected to the preamp? Do they use the AC mains safety equipment ground? There in, a 3 wire grounding type power cord and plug where the equipment grounding conductor, wire, in the power cord is connected to the chassis of the front end source/s ?

Jim