Al, thanks as always for your input. As can experiment, I took my Schiit Sys out of the closet and replaced my Adcom GFP-750 driving my GFA-555 in my upstairs (analog only) system. I also dragged out my old DVD player and plugged it into the Sys. In my small room, I can go just over half way on the volume knob before it gets too loud for me. I was tempted to try hooking up my turntable but wasn't sure how to ground it. I suspect I would have had issues getting the volume high enough using the turntable. I do have very efficient speakers in this room @ 94dB.
I think in the OP's case, as Al mentioned, it would be important to know what source component is being used to cause the symptoms observed. A turntable could most definitely result in the low volume condition.