Schubert, do yo think your preference has something to do with the time each player is keeping?
It seems to me that Evans does not play a set time. Bill Evans tugs and pushes around the beat, and Eliane Elias and Ms. Horn, while quite different tempos, have a more set time, with Ms. Elias even providing the song with a sort of propulsion.
Another excellent pianist who plays around the notes, but still seems to drive the song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tffhDpEmsp8
It seems to me that Evans does not play a set time. Bill Evans tugs and pushes around the beat, and Eliane Elias and Ms. Horn, while quite different tempos, have a more set time, with Ms. Elias even providing the song with a sort of propulsion.
Another excellent pianist who plays around the notes, but still seems to drive the song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tffhDpEmsp8

