1. Home
  2. analog
  3. 1195487022

Should I retip a Shinon red, or replace it? $350

Basically I am getting a shinon red with a turntable that I purchased.

I need a new cartridge.

Simple question, in your opinion should I try a soundsmith retip for $350 or the same amount of cash on a new MC cartridge?

This also brings about the question old MC's vs. new. Is it true that the newer ones perform better at lower price points then the older units?

I know its an odd question, but I have no real area to audition carts. so I am just trying to figure out what to do.

Thanks - Evan
240z4u
dopogue
1,767 posts
 
If it were mine, I'd retip it. Soundsmith does an excellent job.
viridian's avatar
viridian
4,184 posts
 
Why do you think that it needs a retip, why not just have the stylus examined for wear? Pretty simple. If you do go the Soundsmith route, most seem to go for the $250.00 cantilever/stylus combination.
240z4u OP
30 posts
 
Viridian, the cantilever is missing!

I should send it to them to check the diamond, that would be pretty funny.

I am unsure of the differences in stylus profile from soundsmith. I will wait until I have the funds to do the deed, then call them for a consult.

Thanks guys - Evan
psychicanimal
1,738 posts
 
A friend used to have a Shinon Red with a SOTA vacuum. For a $350 retip it's a bargain. You live only once...
viridian's avatar
viridian
4,184 posts
 
Ya, you can really damage your records when you play them without a cantilever, LOL. If Soundsmith can do it, it is a great idea. If the generator is compromised from whatever tore off the cantilever, I do not believe that Peter can fix it. A friend just sent a Koetsu and it could not be fixed. Best to send it to him and wait for an answer. You really can't get much of a cartridge for $250.00 to $350.00 these days.
More to discover