1. Home
  2. analog
  3. 1195487022

Should I retip a Shinon red, or replace it? $350

Basically I am getting a shinon red with a turntable that I purchased.

I need a new cartridge.

Simple question, in your opinion should I try a soundsmith retip for $350 or the same amount of cash on a new MC cartridge?

This also brings about the question old MC's vs. new. Is it true that the newer ones perform better at lower price points then the older units?

I know its an odd question, but I have no real area to audition carts. so I am just trying to figure out what to do.

Thanks - Evan
240z4u
240z4u OP
30 posts
 
Viridian, the cantilever is missing!

I should send it to them to check the diamond, that would be pretty funny.

I am unsure of the differences in stylus profile from soundsmith. I will wait until I have the funds to do the deed, then call them for a consult.

Thanks guys - Evan
psychicanimal
1,738 posts
 
A friend used to have a Shinon Red with a SOTA vacuum. For a $350 retip it's a bargain. You live only once...
viridian's avatar
viridian
4,184 posts
 
Ya, you can really damage your records when you play them without a cantilever, LOL. If Soundsmith can do it, it is a great idea. If the generator is compromised from whatever tore off the cantilever, I do not believe that Peter can fix it. A friend just sent a Koetsu and it could not be fixed. Best to send it to him and wait for an answer. You really can't get much of a cartridge for $250.00 to $350.00 these days.
240z4u OP
30 posts
 
I would describe the sound as "lacking in resolution" LOL.

If its trashed, Ill just stick it in a curio cabinet. I am a sucker for busted carts.

Thanks - Evan
doron
43 posts
 
Hello Evan,

I was wondering - I have the same wonderful cartridge which I managed to snap its cantilever in one second of distraction (and consequent destruction) and since I love its sound I was wondering if you actually went ahead with the cantilever replacement and tipping?
If you did, who did you use for the repair and how did it compare to how it was before the repair?

Thank you kindly!

Doron
More to discover