For more punch in the bass, IMO you need either solid state amplification, or perhaps a KT88 amplifier.
In general, I agree with Onhwy61 that you might be best served by keping what you have.
However, there are a few options if you want to experiment: PrimaLuna Prologue II, Classe CAP-150 or CAP-151, Unison Research Unico P, and Portal Panache.
All are within your price range if purchased used.