Happy with digital, but thinking about vinyl--looking for system specific recommendations

Since your phono stage apparently has gain enough for an MM or MI cartridge, but not a LOMC (Low Output Moving Coil) type, I would recommend a top notch MM or MI cartridge. Sound Smith make a line of MI cartridges that have a good reputation, but you need to be sure the output voltage is sufficient to drive your MM stage. (MM cartridges generally put out about 3 to 5mV at the standardized stylus velocity of 3.54 or 5.0 cm/sec. Whereas MI cartridges often produce closer to 1-2 mV at the same standard velocity.) Nagaoka, Grado, Clearaudio, Audio Technica, and others I cannot conjure up at this moment make fine MM cartridges. I use any of several "vintage" MMs, including Grace Ruby and Acutex (which is actually an induced magnet type). I am currently comparing my Acutex LPM320 to a newly acquired Audio Technica ART7, which is an LOMC type. The ART7 is very highly regarded, and I like it too, but the Acutex gives away nothing to the ART7. Lately, I am tending to prefer the Acutex, but the ART7 is not fully broken in.

Here ya go! Under $500!
https://www.needledoctor.com/Rega-Planar-1-Turntable

The least expensive option may not give you what you want. You could look out for a used vintage table like a Thorens 160 or up your budget to a Rega 3 etc. 
I have a few Croft amps including a 25R. I would strongly recommend swapping out the stock tubes for Telefunken ECC83 or Shughang 12AX7LPS black. Nagaoka MP110 is a good starter cartridge. 

Thanks for the opinions so far. Maybe I shouldn't have mentioned least expensive, and instead said a good value that matches the rest of my system.  From what I've heard, I agree that a Rega 1 is probably not quite there (though it was in a more entry level system than my own).  

@noromance 
I'm currently using some 60s RCA tubes in my pre instead of the stock.

@gnostalgick

What is your budget, ballpark?

$1500 would be easy to do before the end of the year. But I’d rather save more & wait a little--if necessary--than not be impressed with my purchase. That said, if it’s too much more money, I'd be tempted to just further upgrade my digital chain (which I use daily).

The big mistake many make is to think that vinyl and digital will sound the same. Tied to that, many think that different turntables from low priced to high priced will have different SQ levels similar to the gradations of SQ as you go up in price on digital gear. The truth is that vinyl always sounds different than digital and that less expensive vinyl sounds nothing like top-tier vinyl whereas the difference in sound between less expensive digital and state of the art digital-though significant-is much more "compressed". So first and foremost, before spending your hard-earned money-readjust you expectations. The top three contenders are probably the VPI Scout, the Rega Planar 3 and the Marantz TT-15 and you can't go wrong with any of them but among the three, the Marantz is the sleeper. It is a rebadged Clearaudio that offers a few extras for the price. It has better speed accuracy and a better tonearm than the Rega and it is less finicky to set up (right) than the VPI. With all three, you will need to budget another $600-$1000 for a very good cartridge. But don't forget-you need a good perfectly level stand and there is a formidable learning curve when it comes to proper TT set-up. Your last sentence about clicking "play" on Tidal suggests that convenience is important to you. That does not bode well for your interest in vinyl. 

For around $1600 - you can get a Music Hall MMF-7.3 w/ a premounted Ortofon 2M Bronze MM cart.

That's a fairly easy TT as far as adjustments go, very thorough and easy to read manual, and since the cart is preinstalled, that will save you a lot of time.

It's a Stereophile recommended component too, if such things matter to you.

Disappointment rules with entry level turntables, carts, and phono pres.

So what do you consider above entry level?

I'm in the camp of those recommending a vintage, inexpensive table. Full automatic for ease of use. Vinyl is definitely not push a button operation and requires some amount of effort. In my case I run 2 tables. One is a VPI scout mated to a Rogue Pharaoh dedicated to analog and the other (vintage Sony Ps4300 fully automatic) put a disc on platter and push a button is mated to my digital system. If I want convenience I use the digital system. When I am more patient I go analog. Completely different experiences, neither fails to give me joy although I have to say that the analog difference is more pleasure but also more tedious. 

OP, this is an excellent table with great arm and will beat out all those Regas and MDF decks.

https://www.audiogon.com/listings/lis8ig47-gem-polytable-with-10-jelco-sa-750e-tonearm-new-turntables

You could look at the Pioneer PLX 1000 --gets great reviews.

The Gem Polytable is definitely on my watch list.

Any thoughts about the new Technics 1200gr?
Seems pretty straightforward to use, reputedly good neutral sound. Would that change anybody's cartridge reccomendations?

Gnostalgick,

I have the 1210GR (Black version).  It's a fantastic table.  Dead quiet operation, and yes the sound is neutral.

Like the two tables mentioned above by @noromance , the 1200GR also has a a detachable headshell, which makes cart install much easier, IMO.  The tonearm is pretty decent, and comes with an additional weight that screws in the back, so it will accomodate most carts in current production.  I've been using Ortofon & Clearaudio cartridges and the work great.

I would go with the Music Hall 7.3 recommended above.  It's definitely good enough to let you know if vinyl means anything to you.  I bought a Musical Hall 5.1 back in 2005 when I started my mid-life vinyl journey and I was able to understand what the fuss was about, even compared to my then 10k CD player.  This convinced me to move up to a better TT later on.  But if you try vinyl, I would absolutely buy some new or mint used records so you don't get turned off by dirt and noise.  I suggest buying about 5-10 of your favorite albums from Music Direct or Acoustic Sounds so you'll be off to a good start.  I hope you enjoy yourself. I'm sure the Technics is great too.