Terrific how this thread has developed 8 years after the original question was asked.
Here's the answer to the question:
There is no answer. The closest approximation to the answer is whichever player makes you happy, gets you off the merry-go-round, and allows you to focus on the music rather than the equipment, regardless of the method the player uses to get the music off the silver disc.
Here's the answer to the question:
There is no answer. The closest approximation to the answer is whichever player makes you happy, gets you off the merry-go-round, and allows you to focus on the music rather than the equipment, regardless of the method the player uses to get the music off the silver disc.

